Suggestions by @hifumiko

Michael Seater

as Jon in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Seth Green

as Sid in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Samantha Cormier

as Chelsea Harper in High School Dreams

Score: 0

Madison Davenport

as Abigail in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Nicholas Hoult

as Eugene Moss in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Emma Roberts

as Madison in High School Dreams

Score: 0

Veronica Dunne

as Izzy in High School Dreams

Score: +1

Lucy Hale

as Olivia in High School Dreams

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as Seth Stoddard in High School Dreams

Score: +1

Chaz Marcus Fleming

as Petey Jacobs in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Elle Fanning

as Lucy in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Caroline Pluta

as Emily in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Michael Provost

as Chuck Majors in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Miss Trimbull in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Grant Gustin

as Landon in High School Dreams

Score: +1

Garren Stitt

as Benny B in High School Dreams

Score: +2

Garren Stitt

as Benny B in High School Dreams: Best Friends Forever

Score: +2

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Trimbull in High School Dreams: Best Friends Forever

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Landon Teenbeard in High School Dreams: Best Friends Forever

Score: +2