Suggestions by @herondalehawthorne

Louis Partridge

as Nick in Only a Monster

Score: +2

Tom Holland

as Nick in Only a Monster

Score: +2

Lucky Blue Smith

as Aaron Oliver in Only a Monster

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Chaos in Once Upon A Broken Heart

Score: -8

Timothée Chalamet

as Ezra Squall in Nevermoor

Score: +1

Eddie Redmayne

as Jupiter in Nevermoor

Score: +2

Joshua Anthony Brand

as Dorian Havilliard in Throne of Glass

Score: -15

Charly Jordan

as Celaena Sardothien in Throne of Glass

Score: -21

Zendaya

as Aiko in Caraval

Score: -8

Tom Holland

as Dante in Caraval

Score: -21

Louis Partridge

as Julian in Caraval

Score: -5

Samantha Isler

as Eve in The Inheritance Games

Score: -9

Natalie Dormer

as Skye Hawthorne in The Inheritance Games

Score: -15

Zendaya

as Thea Calligaris in The Inheritance Games

Score: -22