Suggestions by @hernameisalyssa

Cassie Randolph

as Piper Bellinger in It Happened One Summer

Score: -3

Michelle Randolph

as Hannah in Hook, Line, and Sinker

Score: +1

Julianne Hough

as Nadine in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Emma Watson

as Wren in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Chris Hemsworth

as Jonas in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: +3

Liam Hemsworth

as Anders in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: +5

Lucy Hale

as Lottie Gardner in A Not So Meet Cute

Score: 0

Bradley Cooper

as Ian Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: -1

Brad Pitt

as Ian Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: -5

Hugh Jackman

as Ian Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: +3

Will Poulter

as Robbie Hamlet in Icebreaker

Score: -18

Cody Christian

as Aaron Carlisle in Icebreaker

Score: -11

Keith Powers

as Henry Turner in Icebreaker

Score: +9

Liam Hemsworth

as Nathan Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: -51

Jacob Elordi

as Nathan Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: +50

Lucy Hale

as Anastasia Allen in Icebreaker

Score: -29

Zoey Deutch

as Beyah in Heart Bones

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Beyah in Heart Bones

Score: -2

Jacob Elordi

as Samson in Heart Bones

Score: +6

Paul Mescal

as Billy Walsh in We Are The Brennan’s

Score: +3