Suggestions by @helenj_

Aviv Alush

as Jesus in The Book of Mormon

Score: +1

Arian Moayed

as Dr. Mahjoub in Foetus

Score: +2

Jake Choi

as Ping Xi in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +1

Amy Sedaris

as Dr. Tuttle in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +1

Sarah Paulson

as Dr. Tuttle in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: -4

Matthew Macfadyen

as Ken in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +5

Ruth Negga

as Natasha in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +2

Bob Saget

as Reva's Father in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +2

Emmy Rossum

as Reva in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: -2

Jon Hamm

as Trevor in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: +2

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Narrator in My Year of Rest and Relaxation

Score: -8