Suggestions by @havingfunsillysally

Aimee Lou Wood

as Alfira in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +5

Paul Mescal

as Gale in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: -3

Jason Momoa

as Halsin in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +2

Simone Ashley

as Karlach in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: -4

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Jaheira in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +19

Luke Thompson

as Gale in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +1

Luke Thompson

as Gale in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +1

Benedict Bridgerton

as Gale in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Astarion in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: -2

Ncuti Gatwa

as Wyll in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +1

Emma D'Arcy

as Dame Aylin in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +5

Florence Pugh

as Isobel in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +8

Jessie Cave

as Kagha in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: +2

Maisie Williams

as Shadowheart in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: -2

Jenna Ortega

as Laezel in Baldurs Gate 3

Score: -6