Suggestions by @harrisonlee3

Christian Bale

as Jack in Jack the Giant Killer (1992)

Score: +2

Scarlett Johansson

as Selina Kyle / Catwoman in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: -2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: 0

Michael Fassbender

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: +3

Jensen Ackles

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: +1

Charlie Cox

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: +4

Andy Serkis

as Oswald Cobblepot / Penguin in Batman Returns (2012)

Score: +2

Jim Carrey

as Jack Napier/the Joker in Batman (2009)

Score: 0

Willem Dafoe

as Jack Napier/the Joker in Batman (2009)

Score: +3

Ian Somerhalder

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: -1

Wes Bentley

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: 0

Andrew Lincoln

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: -1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: -2

Jensen Ackles

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: 0

Michael Fassbender

as Bruce Wayne / Batman in Batman (2009)

Score: +2

Johnny Depp

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman & Robin (2017)

Score: +2

Rhys Ifans

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman & Robin (2017)

Score: 0

Jackie Earle Haley

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman & Robin (2017)

Score: +2

Julian Richings

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman & Robin (2017)

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Jonathan Crane/Scarecrow in Batman & Robin (2017)

Score: +2