Suggestions by @harrisonfunk

Adrian Brody

as Lee Scoresby in His Dark Materials

Donald Sumpter

as Farder Coram in His Dark Materials

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Tony Costa in His Dark Materials

John Rhys-Davies

as John Faa in His Dark Materials

Ian McShane

as John Parry in His Dark Materials

Ian McKellen

as John Parry in His Dark Materials

Rose Leslie

as Serafina Pekkala in His Dark Materials

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Mary Malone in His Dark Materials