Suggestions by @haileyutermark

Benji Krol

as Kurt Kelly in Heathers the musical

Score: +8

Ross Butler

as Ram Sweeney in Heathers the musical

Score: +2

Tina Fey

as Mrs. Flemming in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Ross Butler

as Ram Sweeney in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Shannon Purser

as Martha Dunstock in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Benji Krol

as Kurt Kelly in Heathers the musical

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Jason Dean in Heathers the musical

Score: +2

Nina Dobrev

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers the musical

Score: -1

Lili Reinhart

as Heather McNamara in Heathers the musical

Score: +2

Samantha Boscarino

as Heather Duke in Heathers the musical

Score: +2

Dove Cameron

as Heather Chandler in Heathers the musical

Score: +2