Suggestions by @grand12932

Taron Egerton

as Beast in X-Men

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Cyclops in X-Men

Kristen Wiig

as Lachesis (Fate #3) in Hercules

Josh Brolin

as Zeus in Hercules

Amber Riley

as Thalia (Muse #2) in Hercules

Steve Martin

as Pain in Hercules

Keke Palmer

as Terpsichore (Muse #5) in Hercules

SZA

as Melpomene (Muse #4) in Hercules

Elizabeth Gillies

as Meg in Hercules

Jessica Chastain

as Hera in Hercules

Alan Tudyk

as Pegasus in Hercules

Martin Short

as Panic in Hercules

Danny DeVito

as Phil in Hercules

Melissa McCarthy

as Atropos (Fate #2) in Hercules

Kate McKinnon

as Clotho (Fate #1) in Hercules

David Tennant

as Hermes in Hercules

Janelle Monáe

as Clio (Muse #3) in Hercules

Jennifer Hudson

as Calliope (Muse #1) in Hercules

Tom Hiddleston

as Hades in Hercules

Paul Mescal

as Hercules in Hercules