Suggestions by @got_hard

Matt Bomer

as Apollo in Superman: For all seasons(story private)

Score: +1

Isabela Merced

as Swift in Superman: For all seasons(story private)

Score: +1

Sigourney Weaver

as Sister Leslie in Batman(story private)

Score: -1

Gabriel Macht

as Harvey Dent in Batman(story private)

Score: -1

Rhys Wakefield

as Jon Doe in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Zach Gilford

as Harry Allnut in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Paul Dano

as Edward Nashton in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Colin Farrell

as Oswald Coeb in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Amber Rose Revah

as Detective Montoya in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Brendan Fraser

as Detective Bullock in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Angela Sarafyan

as Selina Kyle in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Gael García Bernal

as Zatara in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Scott Adkins

as Ted Grant in Batman(story private)

Score: -1

Jeffrey Wright

as Jim Gordon in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Colin Firth

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as The Bat in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Delroy Lindo

as Lucius Fox in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Taylor Russell

as Barbra Gordon in Batman(story private)

Score: +1

Nicholas Chavez

as Jason Todd in Batman(story private)

Score: -1

Josh Heuston

as Dick Grayson in Batman(story private)

Score: +1