Suggestions by @godterenorldandotherfunthings

Bruce Campbell

as The Bathroom Cowboy in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: 0

Miles Teller

as Jack Townsend in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: +1

Jesse Plemons

as Spencer Middleton in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as Jack Townsend in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: -3

Isaiah Markin (Wendigoon)

as Farmer Brown in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: +1

Nick Offerman

as Benjamin in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: +3

Jack Quaid

as Jeremy Pascal in Tales from the Gas Station

Score: +1

Johnathan Banks

as Strom Thurmond in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: +2

Alan Arkin

as Richard Russell in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: +3

Jeffery DeMunn

as Arthur H. Vandenberg in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: +1

Nick Offerman

as Harold Stassen in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: 0

Liam Neeson

as Sam Rayburn in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: +2

Larry Page

as Henry Wallace in 1948 Red (TCT) (Wallace’s POV)

Score: 0

Jesse Plemons

as Edward M. Kennedy in Feud: RFK and LBJ

Score: +1

Clancy Brown

as Andrew Johnson in U.S Presidents

Score: -2

Matthew McConaughey

as Father Clarke in Faith: The Unholy Trinity

Score: +2

Owen Wilson

as Father Allred in Faith: The Unholy Trinity

Score: +3