Suggestions by @girlhelp

Cleavon Little

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Score: +1

Don Cheadle

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Score: -1

Jamie Foxx

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Lawrence Gordon in Saw (2004)

Score: +1

Edward Norton

as Adam Faulkner-Stanheight in Saw (2004)

Score: +1

Tobin Bell

as Jigsaw in Saw (2004)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as F**kin' Lou in Fight Club '24

Score: +1

Ana de Armas

as Marla Singer in Fight Club '24

Score: 0

Leigh Whannell

as The Narrator in Fight Club '24

Score: +1

Rita Moreno

as Beulah Davis in Come From Away

Score: +1

Vanessa Hudgens

as Janice in Come From Away

Score: +1

Kara Lindsay

as Janice in Come From Away

Score: +1

Kimiko Glenn

as Janice in Come From Away

Score: +2

Fred Armisen

as Geraldo, a shifty barkeep in the Republic of Pirates in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Score: +1

Andrew Rannells

as Lucius, a scribe on the Revenge tasked with keeping a record in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Edward Teach aka Blackbeard the legendary pirate captain. in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Score: +1

Ariana DeBose

as Bonifacia Jimenez/Jim, a skilled fighter in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Score: -1

Colin O'Donoghue

as William Shakespeare in Something Rotten!

Score: +1