Suggestions by @frachlitz

Bella Podaras

as Vanessa in One of Us is Lying

Megan Stott

as Kate in One of Us is Lying

Carla Gugino

as Mrs. Rojas in One of Us is Lying

Juan Pablo Raba

as Mr. Rojas in One of Us is Lying

Jacobi Jupe

as Lucas Clay in One of Us is Lying

Scott Speedman

as Mr. Clay in One of Us is Lying

Rosemary Harris

as Nonny in One of Us is Lying

Nick Jonas

as Eli Kleinfelter in One of Us is Lying

Alicia Silverstone

as Ms. Calloway in One of Us is Lying

Terrell Ransom Jr.

as TJ Forrester in One of Us is Lying

Olivia Sanabia

as Keely in One of Us is Lying

Lara Decaro

as Janae in One of Us is Lying

Marcel Ruiz

as Luis in One of Us is Lying

Gage Golightly

as Ashton Prentiss in One of Us is Lying

Emma Tremblay

as Meave Rojas in One of Us is Lying

Jordan Elsass

as Jake Riordan in One of Us is Lying

Art Parkinson

as Simon Kelleher in One of Us is Lying

Kit Connor

as Cooper Clay in One of Us is Lying

Daniel DiMaggio

as Nate Macauley in One of Us is Lying

Anna Cathcart

as Bronwyn Rojas in One of Us is Lying