Suggestions by @frachlitz

Billy Magnussen

as Jim Pomatter in Waitress

Laura Marano

as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress

Janet Hubert

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Tatyana Ali

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Ellen Greene

as Diane Gray in Come From Away

Jennifer Coolidge

as Beulah Davis in Come From Away

Haaz Sleiman

as Ali in Come From Away

Taran Killam

as Doug in Come From Away

Adam Pascal

as Garth in Come From Away

Brandy Norwood

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Jayma Mays

as Janice Mosher in Come From Away

Jodi Benson

as Diane Gray in Come From Away

Jeremy Irons

as Nick Marson in Come From Away

Bowen Yang

as Kevin Jung in Come From Away

Andrew Rannells

as Kevin Tuerff in Come From Away

Elijah Kelley

as Bob in Come From Away

Christopher Jackson

as Claude Elliott in Come From Away

Yvette Nicole Brown

as Annette in Come From Away

Idina Menzel

as Beverly Bass in Come From Away

Hugh Skinner

as Oz Fudge in Come From Away