Suggestions by @frachlitz

Mads Mikkelsen

as Hades in Hadestown

Rosario Dawson

as Persephone in Hadestown

Daveed Diggs

as Hermes in Hadestown

Auli'i Cravalho

as Eurydice in Hadestown

Gaten Matarazzo

as Orpheus in Hadestown

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Doctor Madden in Next To Normal

Casey Simpson

as Henry in Next To Normal

Joshua Bassett

as Gabriel Goodman in Next To Normal

Teagan Croft

as Natalie Goodman in Next To Normal

Matthew Morrison

as Dan Goodman in Next To Normal

Emily Blunt

as Diana Goodman in Next To Normal

Alisha Weir

as Frisk in Undertale: The Animated Series

Brent Comer

as Alan in Bare: A Pop Opera

Raffey Cassidy

as Rory in Bare: A Pop Opera

Nicolas Cantu

as Zack in Bare: A Pop Opera

Lisa Yamada

as Diane Lee in Bare: A Pop Opera

Lexi Underwood

as Tanya Garrett in Bare: A Pop Opera

Martin Kamm

as Lucas Carter in Bare: A Pop Opera

Norbert Leo Butz

as Priest in Bare: A Pop Opera

Rose Byrne

as Clairie in Bare: A Pop Opera