Suggestions by @forestexpert3

DeMarius R. Copes

as Crutchie in Newsies the musical

Score: 0

Aimie Atkinson

as Katherine plumber in Newsies the musical

Score: +2

Sutton Foster

as Katherine plumber in Newsies the musical

Score: +6

Aimie Atkinson

as Bird Girl 1 in Seussical (Animated Movie)

Score: +1

Quentin Earl Darrington

as Nick in Come From Away

Score: 0

Ben Platt

as Kevin Tuerff in Come From Away

Score: +4

Jasmine Cephas Jones

as Andrea Deveraux in Once on This Island

Score: +4

Todrick Hall

as Asaka in Once on This Island

Score: +2

Aimie Atkinson

as Delia Schlimmer in Beetlejuice: The Musical (Movie Adaptation)

Score: 0

Aimie Atkinson

as Miss Argentina in Beetlejuice: The Musical (Movie Adaptation)

Score: +5

Sabrina Carpenter

as Lydia Deetz in Beetlejuice: The Musical (Movie Adaptation)

Score: +2

Sophia Anne Caruso

as Catherine Howard in Six The Musical: Movie

Score: +2

Phillipa Soo

as Jane Seymour in Six The Musical: Movie

Score: +2

Merle Dandridge

as Anne of Cleves in Six The Musical: Movie

Score: +1

Brendon Urie

as J.D in Heathers The Musical (2021)

Score: +2