Suggestions by @flamingmidas

Sarah Grace

as Becky Jackson in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +2

Minami Hamabe

as Dottie Kazatori in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Superintendent Harris in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Chandler Lovelle

as Sugar Motta in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Prince Royce

as Dabid Martinez in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Jaden Michael

as Jake Puckerman in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Allegra Acosta

as Santana Lopez in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: -6

Alicia Silverstone

as Whitney Pierce in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Jacquie Barnbrook

as Millie Rose in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Riele Downs

as Unique Adams in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +2

Julie Andrews

as June Dalloway in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Ashley French

as Terri Schuster in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +3

Jack Griffo

as Noah Puckerman in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: 0

Tyler Hoechlin

as Dustin Goolzby in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +2

Jeannette Lehr

as Alma Lopez in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Taylor Swift

as Holly Holiday in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +2

Cooper Andrews

as Howard Bamboo in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +2

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Isabelle Wright in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: +1

Alisha Newton

as Marley Rose in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: -1

AJ Michalka

as April Rhodes in Glee 2022 Fancast

Score: 0