Suggestions by @feltsisch

Taika Waititi

as Easter Bunny in Rise Of The Guardians Live Action

Score: -11

Ty Simpkins

as Jack Frost in Rise Of The Guardians Live Action

Score: -14

Paul Bettany

as Paul in Immortals

Score: +1

Roseanne Supernault

as Gabriella Jimenez in Immortals

Score: +1

Paul McGann

as Hades in Immortals

Score: +1

Nick Frost

as Dennis in Immortals

Score: +1

Talulah Riley

as Persephone in Immortals

Score: +1

Richard Armitage

as Everett in Immortals

Score: +1

Seamus Dever

as Dash in Immortals

Score: +1

Elyse Levesque

as Helen in Immortals

Score: +1

Claudia Black

as Geraldine Hansen in Immortals

Score: +1

Callum Blue

as Theo Schultz in Immortals

Score: +1

Joanne Kelly

as Selene DiSilva in Immortals

Score: +1

Aldis Hodge

as Sanya in The Dresden files

Score: +1

Julia Lee

as Charity in The Dresden files

Score: +1

Lucas Bryant

as Harry Dresden in The Dresden files

Score: +1

Lesley-Ann Brandt

as Lady Cap. in Romeo and Juliet

Score: +1

Harry Shum Jr.

as Paris in Romeo and Juliet

Score: +1

Ann Cusack

as The Nurse in Romeo and Juliet

Score: +1

Winston Duke

as F. Lawrence in Romeo and Juliet

Score: +1