Suggestions by @fehermustang

Scarlett Johansson

as Izzy in Total Drama Island

Karen Gillan

as Izzy in Total Drama Island

Idris Elba

as Chef Hatchet in Total Drama Island

Keanu Reeves

as Chris McLean in Total Drama Island

Zendaya

as Courtney in Total Drama Island

Crystal Reed

as Courtney in Total Drama Island

Mayim Bialik

as Eva in Total Drama Island

Rupert Grint

as Harold in Total Drama Island

Michael Eric Reid

as Harold in Total Drama Island

Alex Pettyfer

as Geoff in Total Drama Island

Dyllón Burnside

as DJ in Total Drama Island

Chris Warren

as DJ in Total Drama Island

Tristan Mack Wilds

as DJ in Total Drama Island

Matt Bomer

as Trent in Total Drama Island

Brant Daugherty

as Trent in Total Drama Island

David Henrie

as Trent in Total Drama Island

Doug Brochu

as Owen in Total Drama Island

Avan Jogia

as Noah in Total Drama Island

Raven-Symoné

as Leshawna in Total Drama Island

Kristen Stewart

as Gwen in Total Drama Island