Suggestions by @fancastunity

Jessie Buckley

as Dr. Kathryn Railly in 12 Monkeys

Score: +4

Chris Pine

as James Cole in 12 Monkeys

Score: +3

Nia Long

as Teyana Taylor in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Rachel McAdams

as Elle Fanning in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +3

Uma Thurman

as Emma Stone in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +2

Rachel Weisz

as Jessie Buckley in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +3

Julia Louis-Dreyfus

as Rose Byrne in The 98th Academy Awards (2006)

Score: +4

Jared Leto

as Billy Loomis in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +1

Jennifer Lawrence

as Kirby Reed in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Amanda Seyfried

as Kirby Reed in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +3

Margaret Qualley

as Laura Crane in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +3

David Castañeda

as Danny Brackett in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Tyler Posey

as Jason Carvey in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Lyrica Okano

as Anika Kayoko in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Neal McDonough

as Wayne Bailey in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Dylan McDermott

as Wayne Bailey in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Elle Fanning

as Quinn Bailey in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Kathryn Newton

as Quinn Bailey in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Bruce Greenwood

as Christopher Stone in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2

Wyatt Oleff

as Ethan Landry in Scream Requels (2022-2023)

Score: +2