Suggestions by @ethelthecreator

Violet McGraw

as Rebecca Morris in The Hand of God

Joel Edgerton

as Deputy McBride in The Hand of God

Joel Edgerton

as Deputy McBride in The Hand of God

Harris Dickinson

as Pete Faulkner in The Hand of God

Tom Blyth

as Tucker Mills in The Hand of God

Spoiler

as The Darkness in The Hand of God

Joaquin Phoenix

as Mayor Morris in The Hand of God

Hugh Jackman

as Jim Weinberg in The Hand of God

Jessica Chastain

as Mrs. Vera in The Hand of God

Robert Pattinson

as Jackson Dean in The Hand of God

Timothée Chalamet

as Simon Washington in The Hand of God

Halle Bailey

as Marie Smoak in The Hand of God

Sterling K. Brown

as Arnold Carver in The Hand of God

Mia Goth

as Beth-Anne Weinberg in The Hand of God

Raffey Cassidy

as Millie Thompson in The Hand of God

Jeff Bridges

as Father Joseph in The Hand of God

Leo Woodall

as Hudson Faulkner in The Hand of God

Victoria Pedretti

as Gretchen Cherry in The Hand of God

Cillian Murphy

as Boone Thompson in The Hand of God

Luca Guadagnino

as Director in Brokeback Mountain