Suggestions by @enderhype

Dolph Lundgren

as Colossus in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Eric Idle

as Nightcrawler in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Nightcrawler in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Tim Curry

as Nightcrawler in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Michael J. Fox

as Nightcrawler in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Robert De Niro

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Bruce Willis

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

James Remar

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +2

Tom Berenger

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: -1

Kurt Russell

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +3

Mel Gibson

as Wolverine in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +4

Geena Davis

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Phoebe Cates

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Annette Bening

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Kelly McGillis

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Mia Sara

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +2

Daryl Hannah

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Sissy Spacek

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Jessica Lange

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1

Kathleen Turner

as Phoenix/Marvel Girl in X-men (1980)/ X-men: Dark Phoenix (1983)/ X-men: Days of Future Past (1986)

Score: +1