Suggestions by @emross

Henry Cavill

as Bill Compton in Dead Until Dark

Score: -2

Alexander Skarsgård

as Eric Northman in Dead Until Dark

Score: +1

Matthew Goode

as Jimmy watts in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Robbie Amell

as Reggie Lucy in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Kate Mara

as Madge Watts in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Robbie Amell

as Jimmy watts in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Willa Fitzgerald

as Madge Watts in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Carlson Young

as Madge James in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Carlson Young

as Nancy Neele in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Katherine McNamara

as Nancy Neele in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Kylie Rogers

as Rosalind Christie in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Julianne Moore

as Mrs. Miller in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Agatha Christie in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +2

Katherine McNamara

as Madge James in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Maisie Williams

as Charlotte in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Nancy Neele in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Colin Farrell

as Deputy Chief Constable Kenward in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as Archibald Christie in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: +1

Saoirse Ronan

as Agatha Christie in The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Score: -1

Judy Greer

as Sheila in The Searcher

Score: +1