Suggestions by @emeraldman
872 suggestions
Sadie Sink
as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers: The Musical
Score: +1
Milo Manheim
as JD in Heathers: The Musical
Score: +1
Simon Pegg
as Bishop Henry T. Dobson in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Stephen Chow
as John in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Fan Wei
as Luke in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Jennifer Garner
as Evangeline Harcourt in Anything Goes
Score: +1
John C. Reilly
as Ship's Captain in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Nathan Lane
as Elisha Whitney in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Coco Jones
as Erma Latour in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Joseph Quinn
as Lord Evelyn Oakleigh in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Jack Black
as Moonface Martin in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Wolfgang Novogratz
as Billy Crocker in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Hailee Steinfeld
as Hope Harcourt in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Sabrina Carpenter
as Reno Sweeney in Anything Goes
Score: +1
Ben Platt
as Quasimodo in Disney's The Hunchback of Notre Dame (2028)
Score: -9
Jeremy Jordan
as Batman in Batman the Musical
Score: 0
Will Poulter
as Aquaman in Casting the entire DCU
Score: +2
Katy O'Brian
as Wonder Woman in Casting the entire DCU
Score: -1
James Lafferty
as Batman in Casting the entire DCU
Score: -6
Lexi Rabe
as Worst Kid in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings
Score: -1