Suggestions by @emerald

Kristolyn Lloyd

as Alana Beck in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Natalie Paris

as Jane Seymour in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Anneliese Van Der Pol

as Belle in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Toni Braxton

as Belle in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Susan Egan

as Belle in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Ryan McCartan

as Fiyero in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Norbert Leo Butz

as Fiyero in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Anna Uzele

as Catherine Parr in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Andrew Barth Feldman

as Evan Hansen in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Jordan Fisher

as Evan Hansen in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Ben Platt

as Evan Hansen in Who has played or will play these Musical Theatre characters?

Brittney Johnson

as Glinda the Good Witch in Actors Sorted By Public Domain Characters

Marge Truman

as Eye Scream in Sort by Tropes

Patty Stanton

as 2020s in Alpha B*tches by Decade

Patty Stanton

as It (1990/2017/2019) in All Fictional Characters Sorted by Media

Manny Jacinto

as Adventure Time: Fionna and Cake in Face Claims Sorted by Animated Series/Cartoons

Kayleigh McKee

as Adventure Time: Fionna and Cake in Face Claims Sorted by Animated Series/Cartoons

Harvey Guillén

as Adventure Time: Fionna and Cake in Face Claims Sorted by Animated Series/Cartoons

Andrew Rannells

as Adventure Time: Fionna and Cake in Face Claims Sorted by Animated Series/Cartoons

Donald Glover

as Adventure Time: Fionna and Cake in Face Claims Sorted by Animated Series/Cartoons