Suggestions by @emerald

Audrey (Little Shop of Horrors)

as Maude Apatow in Characters actors have played or will play

Sally Bowles

as Maude Apatow in Characters actors have played or will play

Toffee (Star Vs The Forces of Evil)

as Michael C. Hall in Characters actors have played or will play

Tobias Ragg

as Joe Locke in Characters actors have played or will play

Tobias Ragg

as Gaten Matarazzo in Characters actors have played or will play

Anthony Hope

as Jamie Campbell Bower in Characters actors have played or will play

Teela

as Camila Mendes in Characters actors have played or will play

Teela (MOTU 2026)

as Camila Mendes in Characters actors have played or will play

Professor Albin Eberhart von Franz

as Willem Dafoe in Characters actors have played or will play

Beatrice (Over the Garden Wall)

as Beatrix in Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough

Beatrice (Over the Garden Wall)

as Melanie Lynskey in Characters actors have played or will play

Ellen Hutter

as Helene / Ἑλένη (Helen) in Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough

Thomas Hutter

as Ta'oma' / תָּאוֹמָא (Thomas) in Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough

Sally Bowles

as Rhea Norwood in Characters actors have played or will play

Lydia Bennet

as Rhea Norwood in Characters actors have played or will play

Sally Bowles

as Katherine Langford in Characters actors have played or will play

Sally Bowles

as Auli'i Cravalho in Characters actors have played or will play

Annaleigh Ashford

as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd (2026)

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Sweeney Todd in Sweeney Todd (2026)

Gigi (Booksmart)

as Ludwig in Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough