Suggestions by @elephantbeard

Rohan Nichol

as Zor El in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Clive Owen

as Jor El in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Bruce Greenwood

as Jonathan Kent in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Cobie Smulders

as Lara Lor-Van in Last Children of Krypton

Score: +1

Tinsley Price

as Young Kara Zor-El in Last Children of Krypton

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as Non in Superman (Arrowverse)

Score: +1

John DeSantis

as Non in Superman (Arrowverse)

Score: -1

Carrie-Anne Moss

as Lara Lor-Van in Superman (Arrowverse)

Score: +1

Carrie-Anne Moss

as Ursa in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Jonathan Kent in Absolute Superman

Score: -1

Brandon Routh

as Zor-El in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Laura Vandervoort

as Alura Zor-El in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Rufus Sewell

as General Dru-Zod in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Jor-El in Absolute Superman

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as Perry White in Superman: Man of Steel (2008)

Score: +1

Rahul Kohli

as Dru-Zod in James Gunn's Man of Steel (2023)

Score: +1