Suggestions by @earthsmightiestnerd
807 suggestions
Hugh Jackman
as Sweeney Todd in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Christian Borle
as Anthony Hope in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
David Tennant
as The Scarecrow in Batman: The Haunting
Cameron Monaghan
as Jack Napier in Batman: The Haunting
Grace McLean
as Jack's Mother in Into the Woods
Gaten Matarazzo
as Jack in Into the Woods
Leslie Kritzer
as The Witch in Into the Woods
Kara Lindsay
as The Baker's Wife in Into the Woods
Christy Altomare
as Cinderella in Into the Woods
Joshua Sasse
as Rapunzel's Prince in Into the Woods
Adam Pascal
as The Wolf in Into the Woods
Joel Grey
as The Narrator in Into the Woods
Anthony Rapp
as The Narrator in Into the Woods
Aaron Tveit
as Cinderella's Prince / The Wolf in Into the Woods
Christopher Walken
as The Mysterious Man in Into the Woods
Lin-Manuel Miranda
as Director in Into the Woods
Neil Patrick Harris
as The Baker in Into the Woods
Neil Patrick Harris
as The Baker in Into the Woods
Andrew Garfield
as Mark Cohen in Rent
Aaron Tveit
as Roger Davis in Rent