Suggestions by @earthsmightiestnerd
807 suggestions

Paul Whitty
as Charles J. Guiteau in Assassins

Andrew Kober
as Charles J. Guiteau in Assassins

Ben Aldridge
as The Balladeer / Lee Harvey Oswald in Assassins

Jordan Fisher
as Peter the Apostle in Jesus Christ Superstar

Stephen Colbert
as King Herod in Jesus Christ Superstar

Lex Lang
as Doctor Doom in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Vanessa Marshall
as Black Widow in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Dee Bradley Baker
as Mr Fantastic in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Ron Halder
as Magneto in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Ramin Karimloo
as Pontius Pilate in Jesus Christ Superstar

Stark Sands
as Simon Zealotes in Jesus Christ Superstar

Baz Luhrmann
as Director in Jesus Christ Superstar

Alessandro Juliani
as Gambit in The Avengers (Recasted)

David Kaye
as Professor X in The Avengers (Recasted)

Jennifer Morrison
as Wasp in The Avengers (Recasted)

Dee Bradley Baker
as Mr Fantastic in The Avengers (Recasted)

David Boat
as The Thing in The Avengers (Recasted)

Ron Halder
as Magneto in The Avengers (Recasted)

Nolan North
as Deadpool in The Avengers (Recasted)

Laura Bailey
as Jean Grey in The Avengers (Recasted)