Suggestions by @earthsmightiestnerd

Paul Whitty

as Charles J. Guiteau in Assassins

Score: +1

Andrew Kober

as Charles J. Guiteau in Assassins

Score: +1

Ben Aldridge

as The Balladeer / Lee Harvey Oswald in Assassins

Score: +1

Jordan Fisher

as Peter the Apostle in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Stephen Colbert

as King Herod in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Lex Lang

as Doctor Doom in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Score: +1

Vanessa Marshall

as Black Widow in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Score: +1

Dee Bradley Baker

as Mr Fantastic in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Score: +1

Ron Halder

as Magneto in Avengers: Universe in Peril

Score: +1

Ramin Karimloo

as Pontius Pilate in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +2

Stark Sands

as Simon Zealotes in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +2

Baz Luhrmann

as Director in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +3

Alessandro Juliani

as Gambit in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: 0

David Kaye

as Professor X in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

Jennifer Morrison

as Wasp in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

Dee Bradley Baker

as Mr Fantastic in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

David Boat

as The Thing in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

Ron Halder

as Magneto in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

Nolan North

as Deadpool in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1

Laura Bailey

as Jean Grey in The Avengers (Recasted)

Score: +1