Suggestions by @dudidudidamdam

Garrett Wareing

as Terry Ryan in Fear Street : Halloween Party

Ella Rubin

as Niki Meyer in Fear Street : Halloween Party

Sophia Anne Caruso

as Justine Cameron in Fear Street : Halloween Party

Melissa McKendrick

as Niki Meyer in Fear Street : Halloween Party

Bodhi Sabongui

as Gideon Miller in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Marlow Barkley

as Dawn Rodgers in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Julia Butters

as Rachel West in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Brady Hepner

as Kevin McCormack in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Mason Thames

as Justin Stiles in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Isabella Sermon

as Lizzie McVay in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Alyvia Alyn Lind

as Elana Potter in Fear Street : The Prom Queen

Ariana Greenblatt

as Simone Perry in Fear Street : The Prom Queen