Suggestions by @drpepper

Austin Butler

as Paul Snider in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +2

Adam Driver

as Peter Bogdanovich in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +3

Miles Teller

as Paul Snider in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +2

Antonio Banderas

as Ricardo Montalbán in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +1

Matt Bomer

as Gil Gerard in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +1

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Patrick Swayze in American Crime Story: Playmate

Score: +2

Michael Cera

as Phil Spector in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +1

Emile Hirsch

as Steven Pennell in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +3

Eddie Murphy

as Vincent Groves in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: 0

Melissa McCarthy

as Nannie Doss in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +1

Jeremy Renner

as Dutch Schultz in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as Arthur Shawcross in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +4

Donal Logue

as Harvey Weinstein in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: +3

Timothée Chalamet

as John Wesley Hardin in Biopics of Serial Killers and Notorious Criminals

Score: 0

Donal Logue

as Alex Murdaugh in American Crime Story: The Murdaugh Murders

Score: 0

Judi Dench

as Queen Elizabeth II in Feud: William & Harry

Score: +2

Michael Shannon

as James Jones in Feud: Fitzgerald and Hemingway

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as Thomas Wolfe in Feud: Fitzgerald and Hemingway

Score: +1

Patrick Wilson

as Max Perkins in Feud: Fitzgerald and Hemingway

Score: +1

Billie Lourd

as Sheilah Graham in Feud: Fitzgerald and Hemingway

Score: +1