Suggestions by @drpepper

Jonathan Groff

as Burt Lancaster in Feud: Brando and Sinatra

Score: +2

James Marsden

as Frank Sinatra in Feud: Brando and Sinatra

Score: +1

Ansel Elgort

as Marlon Brando in Feud: Brando and Sinatra

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Peyton Manning in American Sports Story: In the Name of the Father

Score: +1

Hunter Parrish

as Eli Manning in American Sports Story: In the Name of the Father

Score: +1

Michael Douglas

as Archie Manning in American Sports Story: In the Name of the Father

Score: +1

Josh Lucas

as Cooper Manning in American Sports Story: In the Name of the Father

Score: +2

Cody Fern

as Oscar Wilde in Bosie

Score: +1

Freddie Fox

as Robbie Ross in Bosie

Score: +1

Harry Styles

as Lord Alfred Douglas in Bosie

Score: +1

Vince Vaughn

as Jim Crockett, Jr. in Hot Rod

Score: +1

Jason Segel

as Abner "Longie" Zwillman in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Vera Farmiga

as Evalyn Walsh McLean in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Kelsey Grammer

as Governor Herbert H. Lehman in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Catherine Keener

as Elizabeth Morrow in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as Gaston B. Means in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Colin Firth

as John F. Condon in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Eddie Redmayne

as Charles Lindbergh in American Crime Story: The Lindbergh Kidnapping

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Bret Hart in Heartbreak & Triumph

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Shawn Michaels in Heartbreak & Triumph

Score: +1