Suggestions by @drew2draw

Kara Lindsay

as Katherine Howard in Six

Score: +1

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Yellowfang in Warrior Cats movie [VOICES fancast]

Score: +1

Erika Henningsen

as Anna in Frozen: The Musical

Score: +1

Talya Sindel

as Eurydice in Hadestown The Movie

Score: 0

Jeremy Jordan

as Orpheus in Hadestown The Movie

Score: -1

Reeve Carney

as Olaf in Frozen: The Musical

Score: +3

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Anne of Cleves in SIX: The Musical

Score: +1

Eva Noblezada

as Catherine Parr in SIX: The Musical

Score: +2

Anna Kendrick

as Anne Boleyn in SIX: The Musical

Score: +1

Kristin Chenoweth

as Anne Boleyn in SIX: The Musical

Score: -1

Kara Lindsay

as Katherine Howard in SIX: The Musical

Score: +2

Stephanie J. Block

as Jane Seymour in SIX: The Musical

Score: +2

Renée Elise Goldsberry

as Catherine of Aragon in SIX: The Musical

Score: +1

Stephanie J. Block

as Katherine Plumber in Newsies: The Movie

Score: +2