Suggestions by @dramaking

Sofia Carson

as Tinker bell in Tinker bell live action movie

Score: -7

Dove Cameron

as Tinker bell in Tinker bell live action movie

Score: -8

Ariana Grande

as Tinker bell in Tinker bell live action movie

Score: -8

Kristen Bell

as Tinker bell in Tinker bell live action movie

Score: -3

Taylor Swift

as Tinker bell in Tinker bell live action movie

Score: -6

Taylor Swift

as Voice of Tinkerbell in Disney's Tinkerbell (2020)

Score: +2

Taylor Swift

as Tinkerbell in Disney's Tinkerbell (2020)

Score: -4

Mariana Cordero

as Ariel in The Little Mermaid (The Live-Action Remake)

Score: -20

Ariana Grande

as Ariel in Hercules

Score: -7

Taylor Swift

as Aphrodite in Hercules

Score: -8