Suggestions by @desfitzgerald

Maggie Smith

as Annie and clarabel in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: -1

Stephen Mangan

as Neville in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +3

Elle Fanning

as Molly in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: 0

Dove Cameron

as Rosie in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2

'Weird Al' Yankovic

as Billy in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +3

Scott Eastwood

as Stanley in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: 0

Jonathan Broadbent

as Bill and Ben in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +1

Rachel McAdams

as Lady in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +3

Sylvester Stallone

as Murdoch in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2

Robbie Coltrane

as Harvey in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: 0

Eddie Izzard

as Arthur in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +1

Freddie Highmore

as Stepney in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2

Matt Lucas

as Fergus in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: -1

Ed Helms

as Spencer in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +3

Lacey Chabert

as Emily in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +1

Richard Hammond

as Oliver in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: 0

David Tennant

as Donald and Douglas in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: 0

Steven Kynman

as Duck in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2

Michael Caine

as Toby in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2

Cole Sprouse

as Percy in Thomas and friends new year’s party

Score: +2