Suggestions by @deannasmith

Madison Iseman

as Anna in The Paradise Problem

Score: +2

Kate Hudson

as Anna in The Paradise Problem

Score: -2

Julianne Hough

as Anna in The Paradise Problem

Score: -2

Vanessa Cater

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Brande Roderick

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Brittany Daniel

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: +1

Grey DeLisle

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Andrea Libman

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Erica Lindbeck

as Blaire in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Alex Pettyfer

as Jamie in The Paradise Problem

Score: +1

Nick Robinson

as Jamie in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Cory Michael Smith

as Alex in The Paradise Problem

Score: +1

Billy Magnussen

as Alex in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Michael Cera

as Alex in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Miles Teller

as Alex in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Kim Basinger

as Janet in The Paradise Problem

Score: +1

Madonna

as Janet in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Janet in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1

Simon Russell Beale

as Ray in The Paradise Problem

Score: +1

Tom Hollander

as Ray in The Paradise Problem

Score: -1