Suggestions by @dcrenascer

Mel Gibson

as Giovanni Zatara in Constantine

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Lucifer Mornigstar in Constantine

Score: +1

Rose Leslie

as Victoria Rose in Constantine

Score: +1

Stephen Graham

as Chas Chandler in Constantine

Score: +1

Hunter Schafer

as Anjo Gabriel in Constantine

Score: +1

Morgan Freeman

as Padre in Constantine

Score: +1

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Nick Necro in Constantine

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Papa Midnight in Constantine

Score: +1

Mikey Madison

as Zatanna Zatara in Constantine

Score: +1

Ben Wishaw

as John Constantine in Constantine

Score: +1

Gregg Sulkin

as Superman in Superman

Score: +1