Suggestions by @davidsampson

Clancy Brown

as Johnny Cuba in Tugs

Elisabeth Shue

as Elaina in Tugs

Amy Acker

as Lillie Lightship in Tugs

Michael Keaton

as Captain Zero in Tugs

Dennis Quaid

as Captain Star in Tugs

Jennifer Tilly

as Lillie Lightship in Tugs

Dwight Schultz

as Top Hat in Tugs

Jim Cummings

as Johnny Cuba in Tugs

Garry Chalk

as Johnny Cuba in Tugs

Tru Valentino

as Zip in Tugs

Jeff Bennett

as Zug in Tugs

Nicky Jam

as Zak in Tugs

John DiMaggio

as Bluenose in Tugs

Kevin Michael Richardson

as Bluenose in Tugs

Chris Diamantopoulos

as Billy Shoepack in Tugs

Nick Kroll

as Zebedee in Tugs

Julia Louis-Dreyfus

as Elaina in Tugs

Josh Brolin

as Captain Star in Tugs

Peter Mullan

as Captain Star in Tugs

Brad Dourif

as Captain Zero in Tugs