Suggestions by @davidrolsson

Charlie Heaton

as Matt in Horrorstör

Score: +2

Beanie Feldstein

as Amy in Horrorstör

Score: +1

Stanley Tucci

as Cecil Palmer in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: -1

Rory McCann

as Obliteration in The Reckoners Trilogy

Score: -3

Barry Keoghan

as Larcener in The Reckoners Trilogy

Score: +6

Meg Donnelly

as Megan in The Reckoners Trilogy

Score: -4

Mark Strong

as Dean Nighthawk in The Reckoners Trilogy

Score: +2

Jasmin Savoy Brown

as Dana Cardinal in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +2

Jessica Barden

as Jackie Fierro in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +1

Alexandra Shipp

as Dana Cardinal in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: 0

Tina Desai

as Nilanjana Sikdar in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +3

Dylan Marron

as Carlos the Scientist in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +6

Alexander Skarsgård

as Troy in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +1

Jocelyn DeBoer

as Catharine in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +2

Cecil Baldwin

as Cecil Palmer in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +6

Colin Farrell

as The Man in the Tan Jacket in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +3

Alfre Woodard

as Old Woman Josie in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +1

Rashida Jones

as Diane Crayton in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +1

Margaret Qualley

as Jackie Fierro in Welcome to Night Vale

Score: +2

Kevin Carroll

as Jonathan Phaedrus in Steelheart

Score: 0