Suggestions by @darksith

Emma Myers

as Gabriela in Xena and Hercules

Lili Reinhart

as Gabriela in Xena and Hercules

Dafne Keen

as Xena in Xena and Hercules

Joey King

as Xena in Xena and Hercules

Bella Thorne

as Callisto in Xena and Hercules

Kiernan Shipka

as Callisto in Xena and Hercules

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Zeus in Xena and Hercules

Brad Pitt

as Satan / Lucifer in The Bible

Antony Starr

as Satan / Lucifer in The Bible

Rufus Sewell

as Satan / Lucifer in The Bible

Alicia Vikander

as Eve in The Bible

Taylor Kitsch

as Fox Mulder in The X-Files (Reboot)

Marie Avgeropoulos

as Cleopatra VII Thea Philopator in Cleopatra

Alycia Debnam-Carey

as Amarice in Xena and Hercules

Simon Franglen

as Composer in Xena and Hercules

Hanz Zimmer

as Composer in Xena and Hercules

Howard Shore

as Composer in Xena and Hercules

Ramin Djawadi

as Composer in Xena and Hercules

Quentin Tarantino

as Writer in Xena and Hercules

Peter Jackson

as Writer in Xena and Hercules