Suggestions by @danjunttonen

Jonathan Young

as Davy Jones in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Tim Curry

as Skynet in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Patrick Page

as Kil'Jaeden in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

randy rainbow

as Tails Doll in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

David Fincher

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: -1

Joseph Kahn

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: 0

Rachel Chavkin

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Sam Mendes

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: -1

Bill Condon

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: -1

Rob Marshall

as Director in Villains: The Musical

Score: 0

Chloe Holgate

as Fox in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Skylar Astin

as Shadow Man in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Kenneth Branagh

as Keyser Söze in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Kevin Bacon

as Keyser Söze in Villains: The Musical

Score: -1

Grant Gustin

as Mephiles The Dark in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Darren Criss

as Vrak in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Anaïs Mitchell

as Composer in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Sutton Foster

as Madame Odius in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1

Sutton Foster

as Ursula in Villains: The Musical

Score: +1