Suggestions by @danithrushcross

Alisha Boe

as Jodie Landon in Daria

Score: +2

Alyssa Milano

as Helen Morgendorffer in Daria

Score: -4

Abigail Cowen

as Quinn Morgendorffer in Daria

Score: +4

Barbie Ferreira

as Andrea in Daria

Score: +3

Cole Sprouse

as Tom Sloane in Daria

Score: +1

Ian Harding

as Timothy O'Neill in Daria

Score: +2

Sandra Oh

as Angela Li in Daria

Score: +6

Peter Capaldi

as Anthony DeMartino in Daria

Score: +5

Jessica Chastain

as Claire Defoe in Daria

Score: +2

Michelle Gomez

as Janet Barch in Daria

Score: +6

Lana Condor

as Tiffany Blum-Deckler in Daria

Score: +6

Katherine Langford

as Stacy Rowe in Daria

Score: 0

Alexa Demie

as Sandi Griffin in Daria

Score: +3

Harrison Osterfield

as Jamie in Daria

Score: -2

KJ Apa

as Jeffy in Daria

Score: +2

Timothy Granaderos

as Joey in Daria

Score: +5

Eli Goree

as Michael MacKenzie in Daria

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Kevin Thompson in Daria

Score: +2

Larry Saperstein

as Charles Ruttheimer III in Daria

Score: +6

Laura Harrier

as Jodie Landon in Daria

Score: -1