Suggestions by @danielstouffer

Pedro Pascal

as Thane Krios in Mass Effect Trilogy (TV Series)

+4-4Score: 0

Charlize Theron

as Commander Jane Shepard in Mass Effect Trilogy (TV Series)

+7-5Score: +2

Tyler Okonma

as Lamar Davis in Grand Theft Auto V

+34-5Score: +29

Henry Rollins

as Devin Weston in Grand Theft Auto V

+9-3Score: +6

Kate Upton

as Tracy De Santa in Grand Theft Auto V

+8-5Score: +3