Suggestions by @dan334
68 suggestions
Patrick Swayze
as Riff in West Side Story (1981)
Rita Moreno
as Anita in West Side Story 1961 (Alternative Casting)
Audrey Hepburn
as Maria in West Side Story 1961 (Alternative Casting)
Frank Sinatra
as Tony in West Side Story 1961 (Alternative Casting)
Russ Tamblyn
as Riff in West Side Story 1961 (Alternative Casting)
George Chakiris
as Bernardo in West Side Story 1961 (Alternative Casting)
Ginnifer Goodwin
as Mary Ann Summers in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Bill Paxton
as Roy Hinkley, Ph.D. (The Professor) in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Rose McGowan
as Ginger Grant in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Annette Bening
as Eunice "Lovey" Howell in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Dan Aykroyd
as Thurston Howell III in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Jack McGee
as Skipper in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Andrew McCarthy
as Gilligan in Gilligan's Island (1999)
Dianna Agron
as Mrs. White in Clue
Judianna Makovsky
as Mrs. White in Clue
Dabney Coleman
as George MacMichael in The Real McCoys (2003)
Edie McClurg
as Flora MacMichael in The Real McCoys (2003)
Edie McClurg
as Flora McMichael in The Real McCoys (2003)
Dabney Coleman
as Flora McMichael in The Real McCoys (2003)
Tina Majorino
as Hassie McCoy in The Real McCoys (2003)