Suggestions by @cvnt1

Theo James

as Gomez Addams in The Addams family

Score: +1

Kathy Bates

as Grandmama in The Addams family

Score: +1

Cosmo Jarvis

as Uncle Fester in The Addams family

Score: +1

Cosmo Jarvis

as Gomez Addams in The Addams family

Score: +1

Harrison Dickinson

as Mick Fleetwood in Fleetwood Mac

Score: +1

Jennifer Connelly

as Fate 3 in Hercules

Score: -1

Amy Sedaris

as Fate 2 in Hercules

Score: -3

Marcia Cross

as Nico di Angelo in Percy Jackson & the Olympians

Score: -24

Jake Zyrus

as Eduardo Riccio in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: +1

Alex Newell

as Malik Adeyemi in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: +1

Matthew Morrison

as Oliver Sullivan in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: +1

Jenna Ushkowitz

as Takuma Sakamoto in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: +1

Jane Lynch

as Christopher Hernandez-Wong in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: -1

Lea Michele

as Benjamin Anderson in Fruitful Courage Powerful

Score: +1

Reba McEntire

as Migisi in La Brea Book

Score: 0

Drew Starkey

as Hercules in Hercules

Score: +1

Kelly Rowland

as Evillene in The Wiz (2025)

Score: 0

Beyoncé

as Glinda in The Wiz (2025)

Score: +2

George Stephanopoulos

as Amphitryon in Disney’s live action Hercules

Score: 0

Nia Vardalos

as Alcmene in Disney’s live action Hercules

Score: +1