Suggestions by @ctphipps

Blade (Wesley Snipes)

as Theo Bell in Vampire: The Masquerade

Score: 0

Tony Todd

as Hesha Ruhadze in Vampire: The Masquerade

Score: +2

Djimon Hounsou

as Hesha Ruhadze in Vampire: The Masquerade

Score: +1

Penélope Cruz

as Lucita de Aragon in Vampire: The Masquerade

Score: 0

Ana de Armas

as Lucita de Aragon in Vampire: The Masquerade

Score: +1

Felicia Day

as Lily in Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines

Score: +2

Katie McGrath

as Guinevere Le Fey in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Anya Chalotra

as Guinevere Le Fey in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Priyanka Chopra Jonas

as Guinevere Le Fey in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Cara Gee

as Mandy Karkofsky in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Cara Gee

as Amanda Douglas in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Olivia Munn

as Amanda Douglas in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Milana Vayntrub

as Leia Karkofsky in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +1

Alyson Hannigan

as Carrie England in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1

Jess Bush

as Leia Karkofsky in The Supervillainy Saga

Score: +2

Torrance Coombs

as Alex Timmons in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1

Torrance Coombs

as Lucien Lyons in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1

Scott Eastwood

as Lucien Lyons in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1

Ana de Armas

as Lucinda in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1

Nadine Nicole

as Nancy Loomis in The United States of Monsters

Score: +1