Suggestions by @crystalheddinger

Salma Hayek Pinault

as Sophia in Hidden Pictures

Score: 0

Dermot Mulroney

as Russell in Hidden Pictures

Score: -2

Nicole Maines

as Summer Savage in Things I Wanted To Say But Never Did

Score: -1

Heath hutchins

as Whit Lancaster in Things I Wanted To Say But Never Did

Score: -1

Amelia Warner

as Jen Brotherhood in Wrong Place Wrong Time

Score: -4

Barry Sloane

as Ryan Hiles in Wrong Place Wrong Time

Score: -1

Matt Rife

as Atlas Corrigan in It Ends With Us

Score: -24

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Grim in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +3

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Grave in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +4

Alex Landi

as Stef in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +5

Rocco Nacino

as Stef in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -1

Merah Benoit

as Waylay in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +3

Cameron Monaghan

as Duncan Hugo in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +6

Michael B. Jordan

as Lucian in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -8

Winston Duke

as Lucian in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -7

Alison Carroll

as Naomi Morgan in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -7

Alex Pettyfer

as Nash in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -4

Hayden Panettiere

as Sloane in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: +2

Gina Carano

as Lina in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: -6

Chris Hemsworth

as Knox Morgan in Things We Hide From The Light

Score: 0