Suggestions by @crispytoast

Sadie Sink

as Jean Grey in X-Men

Score: 0

Logan Allen

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -6

Graham Phillips

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -4

Gregg Sulkin

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -3

William Franklyn-Miller

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -1

Zachary Gordon

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -6

Brandon Flynn

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -4

Leo Howard

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -6

Ansel Elgort

as Scott Summers in X-Men

Score: -5

Celeste Barber

as Donna in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +2

Rebecca Metz

as Donna in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Rachel Bloom

as Donna in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: 0

Finley Rose Slater

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Kingston Foster

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Ryan Kiera Armstrong

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Miriam Spumpkin

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Scarlett Fernandez

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Tierney Smith

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Quinn Copeland

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1

Jophielle Love

as Sophia Pelletier in The Walking Dead (comic book version)

Score: +1