Suggestions by @crazycritter
657 suggestions

Alexandra Daddario
as Zatanna Zatara [Earth-84] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)

Katheryn Winnick
as Aquawoman/Ariel Curry [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)

Mary Elizabeth Winstead
as Huntress/Helena Bertinelli [Earth-55] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)
Michael B. Jordan
as President Superman/Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)

Katheryn Winnick
as Aquawoman [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S1) (2021)

Daisy Edgar-Jones
as Harbinger/Lyla Michaels in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Martin Freeman
as Pariah/Kell Mossa in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Ralph Ineson
as Anti-Monitor in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Thomasin McKenzie
as Jade (Jennifer-Lynn Hayden) in Doomsday Clock

Jeffrey Wright
as Monitor/Mar Novu in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Jeffrey Wright
as The Monitor/Mar Novu in Luthor (S1) (2021)

Tyler Hoechlin
as Overman/Karl Kent (Earth-X) in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Billy Zane
as Lex Luthor [Earth-23] in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Billy Zane
as President Luthor [Earth-50] in Luthor (S2) (2023)
Michael B. Jordan
as Superman/President Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Billy Zane
as Mazahs/Alexander Luthor Sr. [Earth-3] in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Billy Zane
as Bizarro Luthor [Earth-29] in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Billy Zane
as Lex Luthor in Luthor (S2) (2023)

Kat Dennings
as Superwoman/Lois Lane [Earth-3] in Luthor (S1) (2021)

Matt Bomer
as Ultraman/Kal-Il [Earth-3] in Luthor (S1) (2021)